Paul gives no commentary for the Demo Area of Petscop 11 or 12, but returns to speaking in Petscop 13's demo sequence, making it unclear whether the game is playing itself (as "Demo Area" would imply) or if Paul is still playing the game normally and simply not saying anything; If the latter is the case, Paul's ability to communicate with Marvin via button presses is suspicious.
Marvin enters the School and the player follows him, inside the school there is a bizarre and out-of-place first person perspective with the player character overlayed on the screen. Green Tool hovers around the screen and seems to be able to be controlled with the left analog stick, but sometimes stays in place, possibly locked from moving with a button press.
After the player wanders around collecting Collectibles and failing to open a locker, when the screen goes black briefly and cuts back to Paul in the Frozen House, no longer in demo mode. Paul asks "what?" and then says "that was an experience". Later, Paul goes back to the bathroom and the game cuts back to the demo area. The player walks into a room where the perspective is back to normal and Marvin gives the player the Needles Piano to play. The player plays poorly and the video ends.
The Demo Area's "DEMO" text remains on screen throughout the entirety of Petscop 12 and Petscop 13, even after Paul creates a new save and does not leave Even Care to venture into the Newmaker Plane in the first place.